Skip to content
Advertisements

Book #5: Gone With The Wind

Quick Facts

  • Gone With The Wind has sold more than 30 million copies since it was first published in May 1936. The book was an instant blockbuster and remains one of the best-selling novels of all time.
  • In fact, the book was such an overnight success that all of the employees of Macmillan Publishing, Gone With The Wind’s publisher, received an 18% bonus in 1936.
  • The book won the 1937 Pulitzer Prize and inspired the 1939 film that won ten Academy Awards and became the highest grossing movie in Hollywood’s history.
  • Ashley Wilkes—one of the main characters in Gone With The Wind—is thought to have been based on Doc Holliday, who was a distant cousin of Margaret Mitchell.
  • The house in which Margaret Mitchell wrote Gone With The Wind is located in midtown Atlanta and is a popular tourist destination and museum.
  • Mitchell was killed in 1949, at the age of 48, when she was struck by a taxi while crossing Peachtree Street—a main thoroughfare in Atlanta and a prominent location in the book.
  • The word “frankly” was added to Rhett Butler’s iconic line from the Gone With the Wind movie. In the book, it simply appears as “My dear, I don’t give a damn.”

The Opening Line

“Scarlett O’Hara was not beautiful, but men seldom realized it.”

My Thoughts

If Gone With The Wind was the 1995 O.J. Simpson trial, I would’ve been a good juror. It was said that it was practically impossible to find an impartial jury for Simpson’s criminal trial because everyone on the planet knew about the case.

How does that relate with this beloved book of the south? Well, I knew practically nothing about Gone With The Wind before undertaking this 101 book journey. Literally, all I knew: the book contained a character named Scarlett O’Hara, a character named Rhett Butler, that the two had a thing for each other, and that it was set in the Civil War era.

That’s it. Even though I grew up 45 minutes from Margaret Mitchell’s house, even though I lived in Atlanta for most of my life, even though I’ve been down Peachtree Street hundreds, if not thousands, of times, I knew nothing about Gone With The Wind. How shameful.  So when I started this book, I was about as ignorant of the plotline and critiques as a reader could be.

So where does one even start when discussing a 1,037 page epic? I don’t really know, so I will let my ADD guide me.

Unless you are under the same rock that once covered me, you know the plot: Scarlett Loves Ashley. Ashley marries Melanie. Scarlett marries Charles out of spite. Charles dies in the war. Rhett eyes Scarlett. Sherman trashes Atlanta. Tara is spared. Reconstruction begins. Scarlett is broke. Scarlett marries Frank for money. Scarlett takes over Frank’s sawmills in Atlanta. Scarlet still loves Ashley. Rhett still eyes Scarlett. Ellen and Gerald die. Frank is murdered. Scarlett marries Rhett. Scarlett gets wealthier. Rhett and Scarlett have Bonnie. Bonnie dies. Melanie dies. Ashley is broken. Scarlett realizes she doesn’t love Ashley anymore. Scarlett loves Rhett. Rhett doesn’t love Scarlett because she always loved Ashley. Scarlett goes back to Tara. The end.

So there: I spared you from having to read 1,037 pages.

The plot is as linear as a novel can get, taking you from point A (Scarlett at 16) to point B (Scarlett at 28) over the course of the book. You won’t see a lot of literary technique here; maybe that’s why the academic types hate this book. Everything you need to know is right there on the surface.

Over the course of the book, Scarlett transforms from a spoiled southern belle into a driven woman who will do anything to save herself, no matter the cost. She scoffs at the female social mores of the time: she marries three times; when slaves leave Tara, she works in the field herself; she works outside the home (she doesn’t bake or sew, acceptable for southern ladies); she travels alone…the list goes on and on.

Throughout the book, she is driven by two things: money and Ashley Wilkes. When she loses everything, other than Tara, after Sherman’s march through Georgia, Scarlett vows never to be poor again. She keeps that promise and becomes wealthy once more. But she can never win over Ashley Wilkes, who is married to her sister-in-law, Melanie.

In the end, Scarlett’s self-obsession drives everyone away—even Rhett—who she realizes is the only man she really loves after witnessing Ashley’s pathetic pansiness following Melanie’s death.

Scarlett and Mammy, as portrayed in the movie (which I have yet to see).

The book is, at times, an uncomfortable read. Every derogatory name you could call an African American is in Gone With The Wind. Mitchell laid the mid-nineteenth century southern culture out there for everyone to see. Everyone other than the poor whites had slaves—even the slaves had their own slaves in some sort of strange heirarchy.

Scarlett’s slaves are blindly loyal, staying with her even after they have an opportunity for freedom following the war. For the most part, they are treated as children—ridiculed when they misbehave and rewarded (e.g. given a watch) when they do well.

The dialect is almost unreadable at times. Whenever one of Mitchell’s slave characters spoke, I almost had to read letter by letter to understand what the character was saying. This disrupts the flow of the novel. One small example: “Lawd, Miss Scarlett, dey pasture dey hawses in de cawn an’ cah’ied off whut de hawses din’ eat or spile. An’ dey driv dey cannons an’ waggins ‘cross de cotton till it plum ruint, ‘cept a few acres over on de creek bottom dat dey din’ notice.” Huh?

Eighty years after the publication of the book, these characters don’t hold up well. To me, they seem to be horrible stereotypes. With the exception of Mammy, most black characters in Gone With The Wind are portrayed as stupid and childlike—Pork, Big Sam, Prissy, to name a few.

Was Mitchell’s portrayal of these characters over the top? I think so. That said, the book is set in a time period 70 years prior to when she wrote it. And I’m reading the book 80 years after that. A lot has changed in that time. But, regardless, a lot could be and has been written about race relations in Gone With The Wind.

What else? It’s fairly accurate to say that Scarlett was a feminist before feminism was cool. She left the house, got dirty in the field, took on a job, and generally did exactly what she wanted to with no regard for the etiquette and traditions of the day. That makes for good reading.

The tension of a woman who is willing to do all of that in a world where women stay at home, bake bread, sew quilts, and cower before their husbands is quite refreshing. It’s one of the main tensions of the novel—making Scarlett into the antithesis of the “Old Guard” and a point of gossip no matter where she travels.

For all her flaws, another redeemable quality of Scarlett is her willingness to move forward and not dwell in the past. When the world she knew totally collapses, she quite literally pulls herself back up while everyone else continues to live in the “old days.” Ashley, for example, could never get over the fact that his uppity, old life of fashionable clothes and ballroom parties  ended when the Civil War came to the south. Scarlett adapted. Ashley couldn’t adapt.

She even carries this trait to a fault. One of Scarlett’s most often repeated lines in the book, “I will think about it another day,” shows her obsession with moving forward even when it means neglecting the realities of her current situation.

The book is a classified as a romantic novel, and that’s the main reason I’ve avoided it, and the movie, my entire life. But there’s so much more to Gone With The Wind than cheesy, Civil War era, romance. I’ve mentioned some of the themes—race relations and female empowerment—but the book touches on the ugliness of war, the power of land ownership and land itself, tradition, self reliance, and loss.

Obviously, there’s a lot to be said about a novel this thick. I’ve hardly even mentioned Rhett Butler. But I’ve got to wrap things up so I can start reading The Big Sleep.

Other Stuff

The Meaning: “Gone with the wind” came from a poem by Ernest Dowson, a nineteenth-century English poet. The phrase “gone with the wind” is used in the book once. When Scarlett returns to Tara, her home, she wonders if it has been torched by the Yankees, if it has “gone with the wind which had swept through Georgia.” On a grander scale, “gone with the wind” is a way to describe an entire culture that evaporated overnight following Sherman’s march.

Highlights: When I wrote my review for To Kill A Mockingbird, I mentioned how Harper Lee seemed to effortlessly drop the reader into that time period. Margaret Mitchell does the same thing. Other than textbooks, I’ve never read much about the Civil War, so Mitchell’s portrait of this dark era in the South was eye opening. I could feel the southerner’s pain when their entire world collapsed under Sherman’s flames, when they had to reinvent themselves and learn new ways of life during Reconstruction. And I experienced their joy when Reconstruction finally ended and Georgia worked its way out from under the Yankee thumb. This was a great portrait of a bygone era in a region of the country that I’ve lived most of my life.

Lowlights: Could the book have been shorter? Yes! Did the book drag at times? Yes! Were slaves portrayed as blubbering idiots? Yes! Did I just read a 1,037 page “romance novel”? Yes!

Memorable Line: In my opinion, this line indicates the turning point in the novel: “Hunger gnawed at her empty stomach again and she said aloud: ‘As God is my witness, and God is my witness, the Yankees aren’t going to lick me. I’m going to live through this, and when it’s over, I’m never going to be hungry again. No, nor any of my folks. If I have to steal or kill – as God is my witness, I’m never going to be hungry again.'” –Scarlett O’ Hara

Final Thoughts: Would I read the book again? Probably not. Would I read a sequel, had Mitchell written one? Probably not, unless it had made this list. But the book, just because of its place in American culture, is worthy of Time’s list. Guys beware: Yes, it’s classified as a romance novel, but there’s so much more to Gone With The Wind than that. It’s a must-read for Civil War geeks and gives a great historical feel for that time period.

Up Next: The Big Sleep by Raymond Chandler (only 200+ pages!)

Advertisements
61 Comments Post a comment
  1. Dean #

    Robert,

    Very interesting article. Whoever made the Ashley Wilkes – Doc Holliday connection must have been on drugs. Wilkes, though portrayed as a man of high character, did not have enough manhood to stand up to Scarlett as he should have. Doc, though not intimidating in stature, was never afraid to take his stand.

    Anyhow, this was a very interesting read, and I know that Susie will enjoy it as well. She is the GWTW junkie if there ever was one.

    DVH

    Like

    November 10, 2010
  2. Yeah, I wondered about that too, Dean. If it’s true, I’m wondering if it was more appearance-based. Perhaps both were suave characters and that’s where the connection ends.

    Like

    November 10, 2010
    • Jillian ♣ #

      Doc Holiday was Margaret Mitchell’s cousin. He had a crush on his first cousin, a nun, and for this reason was booted from the family and headed West. That cousin’s name was Melanie.

      Ashley was not based on Doc Holliday so much as on that family story. (I believe Ashley much more closely resembled Margaret’s first fiance, who was killed in service in WWI.) Melanie, however, was based on the nun. She was an old woman when Margaret wrote the novel, and Margaret knew her. She visited her often.

      Like

      April 18, 2011
  3. Eddie #

    I’m sure its not on the list, but you could always add “Scarlett” to the list… since it was the unofficial sequel. Mom and I stood in line to buy it the day it came out… I think Mom’s copy is even autographed by the author… Alexandra Ripley. Or maybe you would prefer to see how it all ends through the link provided…. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scarlett_(novel)

    Like

    November 11, 2010
  4. Great review and cool idea for a blog. I’ll be back … and perhaps I’ll read a few of these along with you. 🙂

    Like

    February 4, 2011
  5. yearningtoread #

    Wow! Interesting review! Thanks for the insight…looking forward to reading all your reviews!

    Like

    March 16, 2011
  6. Jillian ♣ #

    The first line is actually “Scarlett O’Hara was not beautiful, but men seldom realized it when caught by her charms as the Tarelton twins were.”

    I’m not sure why everybody truncates it?

    Like

    April 18, 2011
  7. interesting review! I just finished listening to it. (therefore no problems with dialog!) I’m not a romance reader, but I agree that this book is so much more. Mitchell does drop one smack into the time period and gets into the heart and soul of the Georgian Southerners.
    At times the dialog between Scarlett and Rhett sizzles–such fun!
    But really, Scarlett, carrying that unrealistic torch for Ashley all those years and to such extreme.
    I thoroughly enjoyed your one paragraph synopsis of the plot!

    Like

    July 5, 2011
  8. I just ran across this post as I’m posting my own Gone With the Wind review tomorrow. The one paragraph synopsis cracked me up! Thanks for the post!

    Like

    September 25, 2012
  9. Ariel Price #

    I love the Facebook-status-esque plot summary. 🙂

    GWTW is one of my favorite books, and I’ve read it a few times now. One word that always sticks in my mind while I’m reading about Scarlett is “gumption.” I think the quote you picked definitely shows what I love most about Scarlett: her grit and her gumption.

    Like

    June 19, 2013
  10. In your opinion, is it a story one should try to complete? I’m struggling to decide, maybe I’ll skim…

    Like

    June 23, 2013
  11. Great review, Gone With The Wind is my all time favourite novel however, I am not blind to its flaws! Like you, I would not put this book in the romance category at all. I can take or leave Rhett Butler, it was Scarlett that had me hooked from the first time I read this novel at 13 and it is GWTW that has had me desperate to visit Atlanta from the UK. Kate x

    Like

    June 28, 2013
  12. There is a great Carol Burnett rendition of Gone With the Wind in 2 parts on You Tube. Also I would recommend Shelby Foote’s “The Civil War: A Narrative” when you finish your 101 Novels. It reads like a novel and yet is a history. It opens with Jefferson Davis leaving the Senate.

    Like

    September 25, 2013
  13. Vishal vinayak #

    Good review.

    Like

    August 8, 2014
  14. Great review! I love Rett… with his irony, humour and…that his patient for Scarlett ulitimately have gone with the wind. With words: frankly my dear I don’t give a damn:D
    Atta boy!

    Like

    May 26, 2015

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. I’ll Rank Them For You, Time Magazine | 101 Books
  2. Do I Really Have To Read The Romance Novels? | 101 Books
  3. Margaret Mitchell Manuscript Avoids Tara-Like Fate | 101 Books
  4. Another List of Top Reads | IF YOU DON'T HAVE A SMILE, I'LL GIVE YOU ONE OF MINE
  5. 75 Years Later, Scarlett Is Still Annoying | 101 Books
  6. The Spy Who Went To The Movies | 101 Books
  7. 3 Novels That Deserve The Harry Potter Treatment | 101 Books
  8. A “Follow Friday” to Fellow Bloggers and Friends | 101 Books
  9. Your Search Questions Answered, Volume 4 | 101 Books
  10. 101 Books FAQ | 101 Books
  11. Next Up: Beloved | 101 Books
  12. What Happens When Poltergeist Meets Uncle Tom? | 101 Books
  13. Authors Best Known For Their First Novel | 101 Books
  14. Authors Best Known For Their First Novel «
  15. Death Match: Gone With The Wind Vs Infinite Jest | 101 Books
  16. Love Stories That Aren’t Really Love Stories | 101 Books
  17. The Readers Guide To Overcoming A Bad Memory (In 5 Easy Steps!) | 101 Books
  18. Book #40: The Heart Is A Lonely Hunter | 101 Books
  19. Next Up: An American Tragedy | 101 Books
  20. Three “Flaming Young Stars” Share The Big Screen | 101 Books
  21. 15 Rejected Marketing Blurbs From Famous Novels | 101 Books
  22. On Stir-Bugs, Skitters, and Truck Skinners | 101 Books
  23. Book #46: The Grapes Of Wrath | 101 Books
  24. Have You Ever Got This Mad About A Book’s Ending? | 101 Books
  25. Literary Characters As President: The Good & Bad | 101 Books
  26. The Whiniest Teenager In Literature Returns! | 101 Books
  27. 7 Famous Novels That Became Musicals | 101 Books
  28. Should You Name Your Kid After Literary Characters? | 101 Books
  29. Creepy Literary Dolls? No, Thank You. | 101 Books
  30. 9 Things To Do With Thick Novels You Hate | 101 Books
  31. The Greatest Literary Controversy Of The Last Century | 101 Books
  32. Who Are The Worst Couples In Literature? | 101 Books
  33. 7 Parenting Lessons From Literature | 101 Books
  34. The Homes of Great Writers | 101 Books
  35. What Type Of Reader Are You? | 101 Books
  36. 10 Book Recommendations For People You Hate | 101 Books
  37. How Zora Neale Hurston Changed African-American Culture | 101 Books
  38. 20 Fictional Characters I’d Have A Beer With | 101 Books
  39. A Prequel To Gone With The Wind Is Coming | 101 Books
  40. 13 College Football Teams Reimagined As Famous Authors | 101 Books
  41. 7 Bad Dating Tips From Literature | 101 Books
  42. Book #75: The Confessions Of Nat Turner | 101 Books
  43. What’s Your Favorite Love Story? | 101 Books
  44. This Guy Has A Dumb Opinion About Gone With The Wind | 101 Books
  45. 9 Book Recommendations For Annoying Family Members | 101 Books
  46. Samuel Jackson as Scarlett O’Hara? | 101 Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: